Guest Opinion | In 2011, PUSD was Thinking About its “Georgia issues” with Student Testing Cheating

first_img First Heatwave Expected Next Week Name (required)  Mail (required) (not be published)  Website  We weren’t the first to recognize that Pasadena Unified School District test cheating has similarities to the Atlanta, Georgia, testing scandal that sent 11 educators to jail.Yesterday’s Pasadena Now op-ed titled “Student testing cheating – Does PUSD have Georgia issues?” compared the Georgia cheating scandal to PUSD’s ignoring evidence that Roosevelt Elementary School cheating was more pervasive than admitted. But PUSD’s now-retired Chief Technology Officer Dr. Gary Carnow saw that parallel 5 years ago. Dr. Carnow was PUSD’s point man in 2011 who “investigated’ cheating at Roosevelt and Sierra Madre elementary schools. In his September 2, 2011, email to 6 PUSD administrators, Dr. Carnow told his fellow administrators “State of California dropped the part of the contract with ETS regarding Erasure Detection in 2009 to save money. There will be no Georgia issues found in California.”Why did Dr. Carnow have a sigh of relief that the CDE dropped Erasure Detection in 2009?The “Georgia issues” that Dr. Carnow says won’t be found because erasure detection is no longer in use in California refers, of course, to the test cheating scandal in Atlanta. “ETS” is the Educational Testing Service, a test development and testing company. The “Erasure Detection” program detects cheating by scanning answer-sheet erasures, identifying the first and second marks on paper test sheets. This cheating-discovery method’s premise is that a high percentage of wrong-to-right erasures deviating from the statistical norm probably indicates testing irregularities such as school employees prompting students to correct mistaken entries. The California Department of Education contracted with ETS for statewide erasure detection before 2009 and from 2012-2013. For budget reasons, it dropped statewide erasure detection between 2009-2011 – the period during which Roosevelt Principal Juan Ruelas showed remarkable test score increases at Madison. Erasure detection became an unnecessary cheating-detection method beginning with 2015 SBAC testing because paper tests were eliminated in favor of secure electronic testing.Dr. Carnow’s email suggests a PUSD culture tolerating cheatingA school administrator who seriously intended to address cheating in PUSD’s schools and who knew that the CDE stopped erasure detection would likely say something like “We’re going to have to buy ETS’s Erasure Detection program in order to investigate the extent of the cheating.” Dr. Carnow’s comment communicates that cheating won’t be detected rather than asking “what do we do to discover the extent of cheating? He is saying that PUSD won’t get caught cheating coaching students to erase and replace wrong answers because the cheating-detection measures aren’t in place – so celebrate and give a sigh of relief that California dropped erasure detection! The PUSD culture reflected by his remarks is an attitude that cheating should be ignored when it can be. It suggests that the 2011 cheating scandals may have only been the tip of the iceberg, with 90% of the problem ignored because it wasn’t on the surface.Additional statistical test-score analysis indicates the need to rigorously investigate Roosevelt’s test scoresYesterday’s graphic chart was a macro-summary of Roosevelt’s test scores which suggests test score statistical patterns consistent with Roosevelt’s cheating opportunities, or lack thereof, from 2009-2015. Just like PUSD’s Board President Elizabeth Pomeroy, PUSD’s Board Member from the Madison District, Patrick Cahalan, dismissively rejects that such data can validly suggest that undetected cheating was going on at Roosevelt. Cahalan offers no alternative explanation for the data. He just says that you have to look at smaller data sub-sets to draw valid conclusions. But the first suggestion in the U.S. Department of Education’s 2013 “Testing Integrity Symposium: Issues and Recommendations for Best Practice” section on “Test-score analysis” is to do macro-examination and it suggests then drilling down to look at “individual student-level data as well as classroom or school-level results to identify unusual trends.”The Roosevelt cheating that Dr. Carnow’s 2011 investigation identified was in the 2nd grade. Statistical analysis of a 2011 class from the 2nd grade is useful to determine whether it is likely that there was a failure to investigate other 2011 cheating at Madison. Statistical analysis of Roosevelt’s 2011 3rd grade testing at “proficient” or higher is thus revealing. Despite having a high English-second-language population, Roosevelt in 2011 tested that a remarkable 97% of its 3rd grade class were “proficient” or higher in English – a statistic that invites suspicion. 2011 was also the last year in the 3-year interval that the state did not conduct erasure testing. What would likely happen If Roosevelt took advantage of the 2011 opportunity to cheat when the CDE was not doing erasure detection but then curtailed cheating in 2012 when it had to avoid getting caught again because the CDE re-instituted erasure detection? The 3rd grade class would likely have significantly lower percentages of proficient and proficient-plus English ratings when the 3rd grad became to 4th grade in 2012 the 5th grade in 2013. This chart shows that happened. EVENTS & ENTERTAINMENT | FOOD & DRINK | THE ARTS | REAL ESTATE | HOME & GARDEN | WELLNESS | SOCIAL SCENE | GETAWAYS | PARENTS & KIDS Top of the News Business News Pasadena Will Allow Vaccinated People to Go Without Masks in Most Settings Starting on Tuesday Community News Home of the Week: Unique Pasadena Home Located on Madeline Drive, Pasadena faithfernandez More » ShareTweetShare on Google+Pin on PinterestSend with WhatsApp,Virtual Schools PasadenaHomes Solve Community/Gov/Pub SafetyCitizen Service CenterPASADENA EVENTS & ACTIVITIES CALENDARClick here for Movie Showtimes HerbeautyA 74 Year Old Fitness Enthusiast Defies All Concept Of AgeHerbeautyHerbeautyHerbeauty7 Most Startling Movie Moments We Didn’t Realize Were InsensitiveHerbeautyHerbeautyHerbeautyHere Is What Scientists Say Will Happen When You Eat AvocadosHerbeautyHerbeautyHerbeauty15 Countries Where Men Have Difficulties Finding A WifeHerbeautyHerbeautyHerbeautyFinding The Right Type Of Workout For You According AstrologyHerbeautyHerbeautyHerbeautyWhat Is It That Actually Makes French Women So Admirable?HerbeautyHerbeauty Opinion & Columnists Guest Opinion | In 2011, PUSD was Thinking About its “Georgia issues” with Student Testing Cheating Opinion piece by DALE L. GRONEMEIER and SKIP HICKAMBOTTOM Published on Tuesday, February 23, 2016 | 7:19 pm Community News Make a comment Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * 3-YEAR CLASS PROGRESSION CHARTPUSD’s Roosevelt “investigation” records are inexplicably missingDr. Carnow’s attitude seems to reflect a PUSD culture tolerating student test cheating. Statistical analysis of both the macro-scores at Roosevelt and the micro-2011 3rd grade class both suggest cheating. With indications of much more systematic Roosevelt cheating than with just 3 students in Roosevelt’s 2011 2nd grade class, we suspected that Dr. Carnow’s attitude would lead to a cover-up investigation rather than a rigorous investigation. So we reached out to Dr. Carnow by email and voicemail to ask him about whether his investigation was sufficiently rigorous, He ignored our requests to talk to him. So our next step was to ask for PUSD’s investigation records to determine how rigorous Dr. Carnow’s investigation was. Instead of getting investigation records, we got a rude surprise.In December, we made the public records requests to PUSD Superintendent McDonald for all documents showing testing cheating investigations at Roosevelt while Ruelas was its principal. McDonald’s January 22 response, through PUSD’s attorney Jeff C. Marderosian, admits that such PUSD files that should exist cannot be found, saying that “[a]fter being unable to locate a file that should exist, I instructed staff this week to contact the California Department of Education (CDE) and request a copy of the Department’s entire file regarding the testing issue at Roosevelt in the 10-11 school year. Staff has made the request to CDE and I will advise you when it is received. From the documents you were sent early in the week, it appears that Dr. Carnow handled the matter and that it involved 3 students at Roosevelt. I have no explanation as to why the file could not be located.” It turns out that the CDE also has no files on Madison’s student test cheating except for a single letter acknowledging that PUSD reported cheating concerning the testing of the 3 students.PUSD needs to hire an independent investigator to systematically analyze Roosevelt’s testing under RuelasThe issue now is not just whether Superintendent McDonald’s rationale for imposing Ruelas on Madison can any longer be defended. His rationale is in tatters and plainly cannot reasonably be defended. There are now broader issues as to whether PUSD has a culture of tolerance for cheating and has been ignoring systemic cheating issues. PUSD’s continuing to bob and weave to protect Superintendent McDonald for his disastrous Roosevelt decision is a recipe for disaster for a public school system that requires transparency and accountability. Dr. McDonald and PUSD’s Board need to end their ostrich-like evasion, face up to the problem by hiring an independent and reputable professional knowledgeable about cheating detection to do a thorough investigation and publicly disclose the complete investigation report, and remove Ruelas as Madison’s principal.Dale Gronemeier and Skip Hickambottom are local civil rights attorneys who represent the Madison grassroots coalition, the Citizens Council for Empowerment and Justice at Madison. Pasadena’s ‘626 Day’ Aims to Celebrate City, Boost Local Economy More Cool Stuff 3 recommended0 commentsShareShareTweetSharePin it Subscribe Get our daily Pasadena newspaper in your email box. Free.Get all the latest Pasadena news, more than 10 fresh stories daily, 7 days a week at 7 a.m.last_img read more

Bruton pledges to implement a development strategy for the border region

first_img WhatsApp Facebook RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR Twitter WhatsApp Homepage BannerNews Pinterest By News Highland – January 29, 2015 Facebook Man arrested on suspicion of drugs and criminal property offences in Derry Twitter Dail to vote later on extending emergency Covid powers center_img Pinterest PSNI and Gardai urged to investigate Adams’ claims he sheltered on-the-run suspect in Donegal Dail hears questions over design, funding and operation of Mica redress scheme Minister Richard BrutonJobs Minister Richard Bruton is promising a special focus on jobs in the border region for the coming year, saying that a corner has been turned and the government intends building on that success.An advance factory nearing completion in Letterkenny will be one of the priorities of that focus.Mr Bruton says there were 30,000 job losses between 2008 and 2010, but the situation is improving…….Audio Player Up/Down Arrow keys to increase or decrease volume. Google+ Man arrested in Derry on suspicion of drugs and criminal property offences released HSE warns of ‘widespread cancellations’ of appointments next week Previous articleStrabane Courthouse pinpointed for closureNext articleMcIlroy two off the pace in Dubai News Highland Bruton pledges to implement a development strategy for the border region Google+last_img read more

London NHS trust targets locals in recruitment drive

Previous Article Next Article Comments are closed. London NHS trust targets locals in recruitment driveOn 9 Apr 2002 in Personnel Today Related posts:No related photos. London’s Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Hospital Trust is launching a recruitmentcampaign targeting local people. Tim Higginson, director of personnel, told Personnel Today that over thenext few weeks posters will appear at local bus stops highlighting vacancies atall levels and reminding people the hospital is only a bus ride away. Advertswill also run on local radio and appear in community papers. Through the campaign the trust hopes to attract people wanting to return topractice, as well as staff for non-specific roles. Higginson said fostering links with the community is important and the trustalready runs mentoring programmes at schools and encourages staff to take upschool governor roles and voluntary positions in the area. “We aim to be seen as the local employer of choice,” he said. Higginson said the trust is also trying to streamline its recruitment processafter it recently lost a candidate to another hospital by half an hour becauseit was still chasing references. “We are trying to get slicker and smarterat the basics,” he said. Higginson is worried that efforts to improve recruitment and retention atthe trust could be undermined by the £5-a-day congestion charge beingintroduced for car drivers during peak hours from next year. He said the charges will also create additional costs for suppliers who willpass them on to the trust. The trust has raisedits concerns to the GLA, said Higginson read more

Awards winners honoured

first_imgTwo Baking Industry Awards 2005 winners and one finalist have been made members of the Incorporation of Bakers of Glasgow, in recognition of their achievement at the awards, organised by British Baker.Celebration Cake Maker of the Year Debra Cunningham and Student Baker of the Year Andrew Fairley, as well as highly commended Daniel Smith, received the honour at Glasgow Trades House last month. Before collecting the honour from the Deacon, Norrie Fyfe, they were granted Freeman Citizenship of the city of Glasgow, which is necessary to become a member of the Incorporation.Ms Cunningham is head of the cake decorating department at 44-shop Skeltons Bakery based in Hull. Andrew Fairley and Daniel Smith are both from Greggs North East.The Incorporation is part of the Glasgow Trades House, set up over 400 years ago to look after workers and their families involved in 14 major crafts.last_img read more

Coronavirus Quick Test Becomes Available This Week in South Florida

first_imgSouth Florida hospitals and long-term-care facilities this week will begin to receive coronavirus tests that will provide results in just five to 13 minutes.The tests, which health officials are referring to as a “game-changer,” will be available at some hospitals in our region on Monday. As more of the tests are made, they should also become available at drive-thru testing sites.Cleveland Clinic Florida, Memorial Healthcare and Broward Health are among the South Florida hospital systems to have the tests already.“Those tests will be prioritized to caregivers, to inpatients and to nursing home patients to ensure they are virus-free before they go back to a nursing home,” says Cleveland Clinic CEO Wael Barsoum.Meanwhile, Cleveland Clinic will continue to conduct traditional testing at its four drive-thru sites, where it will still take an average of two or three days to get results.The hospitals bought the tests directly from Abbott Laboratories, a global health care manufacturer.On Friday, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis said he has asked that some of the rapid tests Abbot is producing also be sold to nursing homes and adult living facilities throughout the state.“They could be used on staff and at least to do some spot checks of residents to see if this virus is penetrating any of their facilities,” DeSantis said. “Many of you know there is a crush on medical supplies and these tests are in demand. We will get whatever we can get for the state. We are working to see if some of those can be applied in a way that can directly protect senior citizens.”Abbott says it is producing 50,000 tests a day and will them ship daily to more customers in more places, with plans to increase manufacturing to eventually produce 2 million tests a month by June.In addition, Baptist Health South Florida has has developed a test in house to get results in 24 hours. “Rapid turnaround time for testing is particularly important with cancer patients,” said Dr. Guenther Koehne, deputy director at Baptist Health’s Miami Cancer Institute.last_img read more